Management Response and Action Plan

Assessment of decision-making quality in the Immigration Appeal Division (2019–2020)

​​Recommendation​​Response
Accepted
(Yes/No)
ActionResponsibleTimeframe
1. Ensure that members assign an exhibit number (e.g. A 1, A 2, etc.) to all documents they accept as evidence, and to mark the exhibit number on the documents.YesThe IAD will remind members during a professional development session and/or by way of a memo to complete exhibit lists and mark the documents with the corresponding label. The IAD is also in the process of migrating from a paper case file to an electronic case file and will ensure the new procedure for labelling exhibits electronically is nationally consistent.IADQ3 2020–21
2. Ensure that all documents accepted in evidence (appeal record, Minister’s evidence, appellant’s evidence) are filed together.YesThe IAD is in the process of migrating from a paper case file to an electronic case file and will ensure the format for organizing the file is respected both before a hearing and after a decision is rendered.RegistryQ3 2020–21
3. Ensure that all documents belonging to a file are attached to the file.YesThe IAD will work with Registry to ensure the process of receiving documents at various stages, including at a hearing, are effective and any gaps identified are addressed. It will also review the verification process at the time of finalization to ensure the file is complete before archiving.RegistryQ3 2020–21
4. Ensure that members intervene quickly when a witness and the interpreter are speaking at the same time, or when a witness is forgetting to pause during their testimony, to ensure that the entirety of their testimony can be translated accurately.YesThe IAD will remind all members during a professional development session to intervene in such circumstances.IADQ3 2020–21
5. Ensure that the issue(s) in a case are clearly stated to the parties at the start of the hearing so that appellants are informed of the issues in a consistent manner. YesThe IAD will remind all members during a professional development session to clearly identify the issues of the appeal at the beginning of the hearing.IADQ3 2020–21
6. Provide refresher training on the following
  1. write in short paragraphs, each covering a single topic, and
  2. make greater use of sub-titles.
YesThe IAD accepts this recommendation and has recently provided training on point-first and plain language reasons writing. A follow-up session will be organized after members have had an opportunity to put the training into practice.IADQ3 2020–21